TL;DR
Get audio and creator gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Andy Richter has said U2 guitarist the Edge wrote a sequel to the 2003 holiday film Elf, but the project was not made. Richter did not disclose the plot, and the available accounts offer no clear explanation for why it stalled.
Actor and comedian Andy Richter says U2 guitarist the Edge wrote a sequel to Elf, but the proposed follow-up was never made. Richter recounted the story in an appearance on The Daily Beast’s Obsessed podcast and again to Page Six Radio; he did not reveal the sequel’s plot or identify a definite reason the project stopped.
According to Stereogum’s account of Richter’s remarks, Canadian film producer Shauna Robertson had been approached about the project, and the Edge wanted to speak with her about it. Richter characterized the script as reportedly fully written. The accounts do not establish when the writing happened or whether the project progressed beyond that stage.
Richter, who had a small role in the original film, discussed the anecdote while promoting Elf Unwrapped: Behind The Scenes Of A Modern Christmas Classic, a book he co-wrote that was released the week of the report. He repeated the story in a Page Six Radio appearance. The podcast video discussion was identified as appearing around the 31-minute mark.
Richter did not describe the story, say whether Will Ferrell or other members of the original cast were involved, or provide details about a studio, production plan, or release schedule. Stereogum reported that there was no clear explanation for the project’s failure to move forward, beyond the account that things simply did not work out.
A Surprising Elf Sequel That Stalled
The anecdote offers a new piece of behind-the-scenes history about Elf, a 2003 comedy that has become a regular holiday viewing choice. It also describes an apparent sequel effort that, despite Richter’s account of a completed script, never became a film.
For fans, the key takeaway is the existence of a reported draft, not a confirmed plan to revive the franchise. Without a disclosed plot or more information from the people involved, it is not possible to tell whether the idea was developed as a serious production proposal, how far discussions went, or what its release might have meant for the original film’s cast and story.
Products Worth Considering
Bose QuietComfort Earbuds (2nd Gen) – True Wireless Bluetooth Earbuds with Active Noise Cancellation
Apple AirPods Pro 3 Wireless Earbuds with Active Noise Cancellation
Bose Lifestyle Ultra Wireless Home Speaker, White Smoke
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
From Holiday Comedy to Unmade Follow-Up
The original Elf stars Will Ferrell as Buddy, a human raised by elves who travels to meet his birth father, played by James Caan, after learning he is on Santa’s naughty list. The film’s enduring holiday audience has made questions about a sequel a recurring point of interest, but Richter’s comments concern a specific reported script rather than a current studio announcement.
Richter’s connection to the film is both on-screen and behind the scenes: he had a small acting role and co-wrote Elf Unwrapped, which documents the making of the movie. His interviews are the basis for this account. The source material does not include a statement from the Edge, Robertson, Ferrell, or a studio confirming the script’s development history.
“Richter said the Edge had written a sequel and that Shauna Robertson had been approached about it.”
— Andy Richter, as reported from his appearance on The Daily Beast’s Obsessed podcast
The Script’s Fate Remains Unclear
The available reporting leaves several central details unanswered: what the sequel was about, when it was written, and how far it advanced. Richter did not say whether the script was submitted to a studio, formally considered for production, or connected to any planned return by the original cast.
The reason the project did not happen is also unresolved. Stereogum’s report says there is no clear explanation beyond things not working out. That description should not be treated as evidence of a specific dispute, rejection, scheduling conflict, or other cause. The Edge and Robertson’s accounts are not included in the material provided.
No Production Plans Have Been Reported
There is no announced next step for the reported sequel, and the source material does not indicate that a studio is developing it now. Further clarity would depend on comments from the Edge, Shauna Robertson, or others who were involved, or on additional details from Richter about the draft and discussions.
For now, the confirmed development is limited to Richter’s account of an unmade sequel. Readers should not interpret the anecdote as news that a new Elf film is in production or scheduled for release.
Key Questions
Who reportedly wrote the Elf sequel?
Andy Richter said that the Edge of U2 wrote it. The source material does not include a statement from the Edge confirming the account.
Was the sequel made?
No. Richter’s account concerns a sequel that was reportedly written but never went into production.
What was the sequel about?
Richter did not disclose the plot. The available report provides no story details.
Why was the Elf sequel not made?
No definite reason has been reported. Stereogum’s account says only that things did not work out; it does not identify a specific cause.
Is a new Elf movie in development?
The source material reports no current production plans. The anecdote is about a past, unmade script, not an announced new film.
Source: stereogum.com
